The Iran-Russia Drone Deal That’s Setting Off Alarm Bells in Europe, America

Analysis

The Iran-Russia Drone Deal That’s Setting Off Alarm Bells in Europe, America

In recent weeks, the revelation that Russia is seeking to purchase Iranian drones to use in its war against Ukraine has set off alarm bells from Tel Aviv to Brussels and Washington.

According to White House National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan, Iran is expected to provide “several hundred” unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), or drones, to Russia. He added that Iran plans to train the Russians on how to use the drones during the next month.

The White House said that a Russian delegation has visited Iran at least twice in the last five weeks to examine drones that can be armed, including the Shahed-191 and Shahed-129 drones, according to satellite imagery provided to the New York Times by the White House.

These reports come as Russian President Vladimir Putin, who has become increasingly isolated due to the war, visited Iran as part of a summit with Iranian leaders and Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, a NATO member who has played a delicate balancing act over the Ukraine war.

Here is why this expected agreement is a significant concern for the U.S. and Europe as well as anyone concerned about the war in Ukraine and Iran’s aggression.

Iran has battle-tested drone technology

Over the years Iran has expanded its influence in the Middle East, through its role in supporting terror groups in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, and Yemen. One key method of exporting its influence has been the development of drone technology.

According to a 2019 U.S. Defense Intelligence Agency assessment of Iran’s military capabilities, “UAVs are Iran’s most rapidly advancing air capability.” 

“Iran has steadily expanded its domestic UAV inventory by developing and producing a wide range of lethal and nonlethal UAV platforms. Iran has reverse-engineered many of these systems based on captured Western UAVs,” the report stated.

Iran and its terror proxies have used drones in several different arenas in the Middle East, including in IraqSyriaIsraelSaudi Arabia, and the UAE. It has also targeted oil tankers in the Gulf of Oman.

Particularly troubling has been Iran’s rapid advancement of its drone capabilities in recent years.

According to a report by United Against Nuclear Iran, a think tank, Iran has accelerated its efforts to develop its UAV systems and transform its drones “into versatile platforms with integrated or suicide attack capabilities.”

Iranian danger to Europe

While Iran has long posed an acute risk to the Middle East, through its support for terrorism, ballistic missile program, and nuclear activities, Europeans have not viewed Iran’s malign activities with the same urgency as Israel and nearby Arab states.

According to Daniel Schwammenthal, director of AJC Transatlantic Institute, the West has not learned its lesson in confronting its enemies, especially Iran.

"If the West's conclusion from Russia's invasion of Ukraine is to confront only Moscow while continuing to engage our other enemies in the futile hope to mollify their behavior, then I'm afraid we haven't learned our lesson,” he said.

“As Iran's plans to sell drones to Russia for Moscow's war against Ukraine demonstrate, we must believe and tackle all our enemies. We must acknowledge that engaging Tehran has so far failed, just as engaging Moscow has failed in the past,” he said, referring to Western efforts with Russian President Vladimir Putin.

Schwammenthal added that increased cooperation between Iran and Russia is a signal to Europe and the West that they must be equally united in confronting them.

“Iran is not just a threat for the Middle East, but as this drone sale shows also for Europe and the West at large. This development underlines the need for Europe, the U.S., Israel, and our other allies in the region, to close ranks against the rising threat from Iran.”  

Threatening Middle East stability

Under President Vladimir Putin, Russia has sought to increase its historic presence in the Middle East. Russia has a longstanding naval base in Syria, which it inherited from the Soviet Union, and sent troops to Syria as part of the effort to aid the Syrian government in its bloody civil war.

Beyond the destabilizing influence it has played in Syria, Russia has also looked to expand its presence in other Middle Eastern countries such as Libya and Egypt.

President Biden’s July 2022 trip to Israel and Saudi Arabia was, among other objectives, part of an effort to counter the increasing overtures by Russia and China to the Saudis, especially as Russia seeks to keep oil prices high to fund its war in Ukraine and keep pressure on Western nations suffering from high gas prices.

Russia’s inroads in the Middle East also pose a potential security challenge to Israel. During the course of the Syrian civil war, Israeli and Russian militaries have had a deconfliction mechanism, in which Israel notifies Russia of any military operations in Syria that could pose a risk to Russian forces. In turn, Russia has let Israel operate within Syria to target Iran and its terror proxies without interference. 

However, Russia has become more critical of Israeli airstrikes in Syria, and has called on Israel to cease its attacks. Israel regularly targets Iranian and Iranian-backed terror groups in Syria that pose an increasing threat to the Jewish state.

Further, Russia reportedly appears poised to shut down the Jewish Agency’s operations in the country. The Jewish Agency is a quasi-governmental organization that helps facilitate Jewish immigration to Israel as well as other community advocacy and work.  

Bolstering Russia’s capabilities in Ukraine

For decades, Russia has been seen as a weapons exporter. Yet, reports indicate that Russia has been depleting its weapons arsenal as the war continues and Ukraine is being bolstered by advanced Western weaponry, including the HIMARS system, an armored-vehicle-mounted long-range artillery launcher that has enabled Ukrainian forces to hit Russian targets dozens of miles away with precision.

AJC has advocated for the U.S. to take several measures to support Ukraine and isolate Russia, including providing critical military aid to the besieged nation. Speaking to AJC Global Forum 2022, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky thanked AJC for its “substantive help” and called on supporters to redouble their efforts to stop Russia.

To counter this, it appears Russia is leaning on rogue states such as Iran, with which the country has a longstanding relationship, especially in the Syrian civil war, to replenish its drone arsenal.

A U.K. Ministry of Defence intelligence report said that Russia has suffered a high attrition rate of its drones, in particular its reconnaissance UAVs.

“Russia has attempted to implement the concept of ‘Reconnaissance Strike’ it refined in Syria, which uses reconnaissance UAVs to identify targets to be struck by combat jets or artillery,” the intelligence report said.

It added that if Russia continued to lose UAVs, “Russian forces intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance capability will be further degraded,” and this would “negatively” affect their ability to fight.

CIA Director William Burns said that Russia’s interest in buying Iranian drones reflects the poor state of its military.

“It’s true that the Russians are reaching out to the Iranians to try to acquire armed drones,” he said, Bloomberg News reported.

“They need each other, they don’t really trust each other, in the sense that they’re energy rivals and historical competitors,” Burns said, adding that the purported deal is a reflection “of the deficiencies of Russia’s defense industry today, and the difficulties they’re having after significant losses so far in the war against Ukraine.”

White House National Security Advisor Sullivan said that the U.S. will continue to stand by Ukraine as Russia continues its aggression.

“We will continue to do our part to help sustain the effective defense of Ukraine and to help the Ukrainians show that the Russian effort to try to wipe Ukraine off the map cannot succeed.”